service first insurance agency

Calloway Insurance is the Insurance Agency of choice dedicated to serving others for over 20 years.

Dear Valued Customer,

Calloway Insurance Agency, Inc is a family-owned business that takes to heart the insurance needs of you and your family. The Calloway story is more than 20 years in the making when I became licensed in 2000. I built my customer base by establishing relationships with business owners and joining seven distinct networking groups. When I was ready for the commitment, I opened my family business in 2003. My passion is to help clients choose the right products while also saving them money.

If it seems like insurance is more complicated than the tangle of wires underneath your desk, you’re not alone. The Calloway Family will answer your questions and help you untangle issues that may arise. We are a full-service brokerage licensed in Missouri and Illinois, and we look forward to doing business with you.


kay Calloway, Founder

Adam Calloway


Adam joined the business in the summer of 2007. He specializes in commercial, Personal, Health, and Life insurance. He has been married for 19 years and has 5 kids. He volunteers at his local church, loves to hang out with his family by the pool, and enjoys taking his family dirt biking. Adam likes telling funny stories and never fails to make people laugh.

Alyssa Mottert


Since 2014, Alyssa has been a licensed Agent at Calloway Insurance Agency. She specializes in Commercial, Personal, and Life insurance. She graduated from St. Louis Community College in 2015. Outside of work, she enjoys hiking and traveling with her Husband.

Paige Bauer


Paige joined Calloway Insurance Agency in November of 2021 as a personal lines agent. As a personal lines agent, Paige focuses on providing home, auto, watercraft and rental insurance for their clients. Paige’s favorite part of working at Calloway Insurance Agency is working for an agency that has a great relationship with each of their clients. In her time away from work she is building a home that will allow a space to create memories with her family and most importantly, her pet pug.